In
the Third chapter of "The Truly Disadvantaged," by William Julius
Wilson he talks about poverty and how it has affected the family structure. He
talked about how there was a disproportionate increase in single parent
households between white families and black families from 1960 until the end of
the 1980's. One of the theories that became popular to try to understand why
this was happening was that the increase in government assistance, through
programs such as Medicaid and welfare, lead to the increase in female led
households, with the rate of black mother led households increasing faster than
white mother led households. This popular theory was embraced for a
while, but eventually fell out of favor due to the lack of evidence that could
support the argument. Instead, there were a few other factors that contributed
to the increase in single parent household’s disparity between black families and
white families: the rate of “marriageable males,” for white women decreased
slightly between 1960 and 1980, whereas that number for black women decreased
significantly. One of the key points in the book that I thought was interesting
was the fact that black women who run a single parent household are more likely
to remain in poverty for a long period of time as opposed to white women who don’t
come out of poverty quicker and more often. “Most white women can maintain their
families above poverty with a combination of earnings and income from other
sources such as alimony, child support, public-income transfers, personal
wealth, and assistance from families… in addition, many white single mothers
remarry,” (Wilson 77). I found the fact that white women remarry at larger
rates than black men to be interesting, coming from a single parent household I
was surrounded by that environment but thinking about it from that perspective
never occurred to me. You see this portrayed in a lot of films. One of the
first films that came to mind when I thought of how common it was for white
families to remarry was the film Parent Trap. It’s a film a lot of kids raised
in the 90’s grew up with, the film is about a set of twins that got separated
at birth by their parents after they decide to get a divorce. The father of the
twins gets a new finance and when the twins find out that they were separated
at birth, they set a plan in motion to get their parents back together.
The
importance of “marriageable father,” in a family structure as it relates to
poverty reminded me of the film the Pursuit of Happyness. In this film, the father
is barely making ends meet and is pretty much homeless with his 5 year old son,
he banks his entire livelihood on an unpaid competitive internship that would
get him a well-paying job should he succeed. The father is sort of with the
mother in the movie, but their relationship is clearly strained and she barely
takes part in raising her child. There’s a scene in the movie where the father
and son sleep inside of a men’s bathroom and when someone tries to come in, the
father has to hold the door shut with his foot. To me this represented the
epitome of living in poverty. Another thing I found interesting is how single
parent households have become socially accepted to the point where it is
uncommon to see a black family with both the mother and father actively
present. There is a hip hop artist by the name of Childish Gambino who said “This
one kid said something that was really bad. He said I wasn't really black
because I had a dad. I think that's kind of sad. Mostly cause a lot of black
kids think they should agree with that,” in his song Hold You Down, which goes
to show that blacks being raised in a single parent household has become so
accepted in our society, it has become synonymous with blackness.
First of all, I really felt that you did a good job covering Wilson’s points from chapter 3, and then tying those points to your own ideas and opinions. Secondly, the pursuit of happiness was a great choose to show the effect of single parent households. Especially those households who are already barely making enough to make it as it is. By providing the pursuit of happiness as an example, I felt it really gave the readers of your blog a great visual representation of what hardships these single family households really had to go through in their daily lives. You also discussed the difference between African American single family households and white single family households. Your examples the parent trap and the pursuit of happiness paired perfectly together, by providing a visual example of both sides of the spectrum. Touching back on your example of the parent trap, this was a perfect example to show how for white single family households, there is usually always outside help that will keep them out of poverty. An example from the movie one of the daughters who lived in England, they lived with her grandfather who was clearly very wealthy. Being that he was very well off, his daughter never even would have come close to poverty, because he would be able to help her. But, overall I felt this was a really well thought out blog post, with excellent examples that perfectly described what you were talking about.
ReplyDelete